Not trying to argue with you..but you're trying to re-invent the wheel. The evidence of adverse ZDDP reduction on flat tappet cams is already well documented ad-nauseum. If you choose not to believe it, that's your choice. As for myself, I have seen plenty of older flat tappet engines destroyed by using these new " Energy Star " motors. Mainly in Detroit Muscle cars but also a lot of Vintage British cars. It was an issue 10 years ago and still is today.
I doubt that a Poll will reveal much in this particular case. The stock Nissan L series valve train has excellent metallurgy. That is a proven and documented fact. And it's going to have a very small data pool. And if you use a 10/40 wt or higher motor oil you will probably not run into the problem as these are not considered " Energy Star " classification.
The problems are rampant in Forums outside of Nissan/Datsun, in engines that use flat tappet cams, such as GM, Ford, Pontiac, Chrysler VW/Audi etc. Those are the ones that are full of failures directly due to ZDDP reduction. And there are literally Millions of data points out there. I've seen enough first hand and trust the advice of the Professional engine builders that I deal with to convince me. Mind you, I've been an Amsoil user for over 20 years.. but even Amsoil has recently changed and it's oils aren't as good as they once were.
As far as theory vs actual fact? I trust the results of independent oil testing laboratories such as Blackstone Labs. And white papers by SAE and technical articles on Motor oils by Race Car Engineering, Race Car Tech, Race Car Engine, David Vizard, Joe Gibbs Racing, my engine building shops and others.
With respect, just because you or a small sampling of people don't have a problem does not mean the problem doesn't exist